Not-Charlie declined his offer, instead asking if John was down for another date at the Italian place later. Officer Clay and John plan to meet up to discuss Charlie's behavior since Charlie also refused her old doll Ella from the house wreckage. Not-Charlie ignored this, simply replying that John had seen Charlie's dorm six months earlier that was much messier. After he left Clay's house and began walking to his car, Charlie saw John outside on the sidewalk and walked over to John.

William, in the real world, saw that Carlton looked dead and decided to go after Jacob and inject him with remnant as an experiment as well. However, they see a house with a star on it, remembering Theodore had also mentioned a shining star. As she moved closer, Not-Charlie transformed into Circus Baby and Carlton put the earpiece into his ear. She forces Jessica to perform surgery on a dying William Afton who has escaped the SpringBonnie suit. Charlie had miraculously reappeared the day after her death, but John couldn't bring himself to believe that it was actually Charlie, thinking it was an impostor.Baby also recounted the story of Elizabeth Afton, the girl that now possessed the Circus Baby animatronic. John then asked Charlie about her project from six months ago and how it had the earpieces that made humans visible to the robots. The spirits of the children William murdered suddenly remembered the truth of what happened and the Amalgamation attacked William. I wouldn't necessarily recommend the series, but if you're a diehard fan looking at every work for hints towards the true plot of FNAF overall, many theorists have cited at least a couple of things shown in these books that are not as clear in the games, so it might be worth it just for the sake of consideration and further theorizing.

They mentioned that the Charlie that had been around the past six months had acted differently and that Theodore had given them a message to come here. Jessica then asked if he was done 'cleaning', to which John said yes and opened his door for Not-Charlie and Jessica. Honestly, the best way I can describe the Fourth Closet is like a fever dream, and a mind fuck in places.One strength that I saw with this graphic novel was that the illustrations for this book were very detailed, which gave me different feelings for each character when I read it.